Broken Toys of the Motor City's Nobility

Hidden somewhere in one of the many slips that line the Detroit River sits an old forgotten motor yacht from Detroit's golden era, named Helene. She was owned by Charles E. Sorenson, who was one of Henry Ford's highest-ranking lieutenants—once upon a time among the most powerful and feared men in the Motor City.

Sorenson was a master mechanic and patternmaker who helped Ford design the prototype for the Model T, and he was also instrumental in the first moving assembly line experiments at the Piquette Plant. He was the chief mastermind tasked with implementing the new assembly line idea at the Highland Park Plant, and making sure it was a logistical success. An article in Hemmings Motor News by Jim Donnelly even goes as far as to say that Sorenson was literally the "architect" of the Ford Motor Company's rise as a global power, while "old man Henry" was merely the face behind its products.


The 106-foot boat was named after Mr. Sorenson's wife Helen, and built in 1927 by the renowned Defoe Shipbuilding Co. in Bay City, Michigan. According to one source, she was constructed as a "temporary vessel" for Sorenson until a larger one could be built, which is surprising since the Great Depression intervened soon after and even the wealthy were forced to make ghastly sacrifices, such as tolerating yacht shortages. Then again, Sorenson was one of Detroit's richest men after all.

According to an old thread on boatnerd.comHelene is one "of the last" of the classic 1920s "commuter yachts" still left on the lakes. Probably the most famous of these would have been the Delphine, owned by the Dodge brothers. I have no doubt that Sorenson would have used the lesser-known Helene to report to work at the Rouge Plant on occasion, by sailing up the Rouge River.


Sorenson was Ford's "production boss," meaning he was the one who had to make sure the plant's output was high and costs were low. When Henry Ford made the ridiculous assertion during WWII that he could build a plant to make 1,000 airplanes a day, it was Sorenson who was put in charge of making it happen—the Willow Run Bomber Plant was the result. Although the "1,000-planes-a-day" claim was never met, Willow Run's eventual production capability was an incredible "bomber-an-hour."

According to Sorenson's biography, My Forty Years with Ford, his lifelong passion for the water stemmed from his childhood in Buffalo where he often rafted on the Niagara River. He owned a series of vessels, most notably the Helene. Despite its gorgeous polished wood and brass, and its large stateroom with a king-size bed, its open decks were said to have been a drawback, meaning that guests would have to go outside into the weather to go between the lounge and the dining salon. Ghastly!


The book Ford: The Man, The Times, The Company, by Allan Nevins described Sorenson as tall and Danish, handsome, energetic, and mentally keen. But he was also given to fits of "grim moodiness," and described as "iron-handed," with an "explosive temper." Then again I suppose that could describe anyone who was forced to tolerate (or who was able to tolerate) working with Henry Ford for an extended period of time. It might be going too far to say that Sorenson was hated amongst Ford workers, but he was certainly seen as something of a slave-driver, who had the ability to strike fear into the men—one of the very qualities that endeared him to Mr. Ford. He soon earned the nickname of "Cast-Iron Charlie."

Henry's son Edsel however despised Sorenson, for his tendency to scream at people or use threats to scare the workers into speeding up. When Edsel Ford took over the company presidency in 1919 he immediately canned Sorenson, but Henry went over his head and had Sorenson rehired (which was probably when everybody realized that Edsel had merely been installed as a puppet so his father could legally buy up a controlling majority of the company's stock).


Sorenson was one of Henry Ford's "lieutenants," meaning that he was often the taskmaster who carried out Mr. Ford's dirty work. Henry depended on his lieutenants but he also played them against one another to see which one would prove stronger or more loyal. William Knudsen was another prominent engineer of Danish descent who Henry hired to oversee production, though it was quickly evident to Knudsen that his job essentially duplicated Sorenson's. Henry no doubt did this so as to force the two men to compete out of a fear of looking inferior to the other in the eyes of their shrewd master.

Naturally the person who profited from this gladiatorial combat was Mr. Ford—he had the two best production engineers in the country working as hard as they could for him to prove their mettle. Knudsen allegedly finally went to Ford to complain and demand that he choose between Sorenson and himself, but Ford merely blew it off. Knudsen eventually resigned, and went on to become the president of General Motors.


By the time the Rouge Plant superseded the Highland Park Plant as the seat of Ford's empire, Sorenson was the unchallenged czar of everything that went on within that massive new industrial fortress, with only Harry Bennett—Ford's personal bodyguard—above him in power.

Sorenson became so synonymous with the way the Rouge operated that it was widely thought that he was one of the evil managers portrayed as prowling about the corners of the famous Diego Rivera mural that serves as the centerpiece of the Detroit Institute of Arts. The mural was considered so scandalous for the way it portrayed the evils of "Fordism" when it was unveiled in 1933 that it might have been destroyed, if not for Edsel stepping in to prevent his father from doing so (Henry was apparently under the impression that the mural would glorify Ford). The DIA later asserted that the portrayal was not of Sorenson, but more likely that of his lackey, the despised Mead L. Bricker.


Charles Sorenson was the commodore of the Detroit Yacht Club, and a member of the Grosse Pointe Yacht Club, as well as sailing clubs in Miami Beach and the Bahamas. The same year the Helene was built, the Sorensons built a house on Miami Beach where they spent Christmastime. Prior to 1923 they lived in an old farmhouse in what became Rouge Park, as I wrote about in another post. After Mr. Sorenson became more nautically inclined, he lived in the Detroit Towers at 8162 East Jefferson, overlooking the Detroit River and Belle Isle. Undoubtedly that was a convenient residence, since he could probably dock there.

The author of My Forty Years with Ford wrote that Henry Ford II recalled seeing Sorenson walking around the Ford Rouge plant in wintertime with his collar turned up against the cold because he had gotten used to the warm Florida weather. Miami Beach had actually been turned into quite the elite resort thanks to snowbird Detroit auto barons like Sorenson, Carl G. Fisher, and Ransom Olds.

Photo by Cavemonkey
By the time of Edsel's early death, Sorenson had become vice-president of Ford Motor, and was perhaps the only employee still left who had been there since the beginning. It was thought that Sorenson would step into the presidency, but Henry surprised everyone again by resuming the company presidency until his own death. Sorenson was instead railroaded out of the company shortly after, (allegedly) partly because Harry Bennett had it out for him, and (allegedly) partly because Clara Ford thought he would keep Henry Ford II from his rightful place as heir. Such was life in the ranks of the Ford Motor Company. In 1944 Sorenson resigned and moved to Miami Beach.


Jim Donnelly's article goes on to mention that Sorenson also briefly acted as president of Willys-Overland after leaving Ford, where he oversaw the creation of a civilian version of the Jeep for the post-war market. He died in 1968, having probably lived long enough to see that vehicle become almost as revolutionary as the Model-T had been.


A post on yachtspotter.com by a man claiming to be the grandson of Charles E. Sorensen indicates that there was indeed a second Helene built by the Bath Iron Works in Maine and launched in 1931, and that the first Helene was sold into the charter business. He said their family spent "many summer afternoons cruising the St. Clair River" near Algonac, where she was berthed behind their summer home.

When My Forty Years with Ford was written, this yacht was then owned by Shamrock Chartering Co. of Grosse Pointe, who used it for cruises as an excursion boat. Sorenson also owned a racing yacht named White Cloud, "which was well known in southern waters."


Helene's exterior woodwork was all teak, "salvaged from a U.S. Navy vessel" supposedly, and the structural members were of select grade Douglass fir. The Helene was powered by twin Detroit Diesels, producing a combined 1,050 horsepower. Sounds like Helene could boogie if she wanted to.


Another comment elsewhere online said that while in lay-up here Helene had once lost power and her bilge pumps died, causing her to sink at the dock. Reportedly her bow was damaged when they raised her again.


Up in the pilothouse, I was pleased to see that Helene had one of the classic style wooden helms, but photography was a bit tricky with the light coming in through the windows from the east:


One of the other posts on boatnerd.com says that the owners were reportedly doing restoration work on Helene, hoping to be done in time to salvage some of the 2005 boating season. Since she is still sitting here a decade later in some state of disassembly tells me that not all has gone as planned.


Another person on boatnerd.com said that he crewed aboard the Helene around 1978 when it was used as a private charter craft by the Verbiest family, and lived in the crew quarters on the boat for the summer. He said that the Helene got a lot of use back then, taking people on excursions sometimes six days per week.
The most memorable trip was when the family took her to Mackinaw Island, through the Soo Locks into Lake Superior, and under the big Mackinac Bridge just into Lake Michigan. I can't say all of the trip was smooth sailing. Crossing Saginaw Bay heading north had waves crashing over the bow, and I turned several shades of green. With some ribbing and advice from Capt. Bill Graham, I think I managed to keep breakfast where it belonged.

I should have gone below decks to see that large stateroom and other quarters that would have been down there, but my crewmate alerted me to the presence of authorities who were in the area. The sheriff's patrolboat had been buzzing around in the area and we were pretty sure he was trying to figure out where we had disappeared to.

Here is what looks to have been the lounge perhaps, in the forward-most compartment above deck...


...and once again balancing the light situation was tricky—especially when rushed due to the fact that the law was lurking near.


So that my craft's sudden disappearance would not seem overly suspicious, I jumped back aboard after shooting these few quick snaps, and we got underway again under the guise of harmless fishermen. There are also security personnel on land who patrol the area where Helene is moored (and probably cameras on the shipyard as well), so unfortunately unless you can bring the stealth like a Navy SEAL diver, this is about as good as it gets.

Photo by Cavemonkey
We decided to putter around to some other places of interest in the area. There is another sunken wreck near the Helene, an old railroad ferry named the Detroit, which you can see in this aerial view:


We apparently passed right by this wreck without my seeing it, though I believe my crewmate might have said he saw something.

We then continued on to Grassy Island where I saw this decrepit old marker listing dangerously, almost as if ready to tip over completely and fall off its little islet.


There is not much on Grassy Island itself, except perhaps the faintest traces of an old lighthouse that was there in the 1870s, but in any case I was having trouble even with my extraordinarily shallow-drafting boat to get close enough to it in order to make a landing, thanks to its being surrounded by a girdle of treacherous shoals.


This thing looked interesting though, so I moved in as close as I dared:


This was about as close as I could bring us, in light of the many rocks that were here.


Great Lakes Steel's Ecorse Works looked even more imposing from the water than it does from land:


I talk more about Great Lakes Steel in another post. On our way back to the launch we passed Zug Island, and saw this busted old pumphouse or whatever it is:


Since I've always wanted to be able to say I've been on Zug Island, we decided to pull over this time and investigate.


A good portion of it had collapsed.


This spot sits across the channel from where the old Detroit Sulphite Pulp & Paper Co. used to be.


Not much was inside.


Normally U.S. Steel's corporate security thugs will try to accost you for photographing their mill from land, under the cockamamie pretense that it is prohibited by "Homeland Security," but they were going to need some water wings if they were going to harass me today:


My 14-foot boat next to the 1,004-foot ore carrier, Edwin H. Gott...which was not underway at the time, otherwise I would never have dared get this close:


Love that river in the summertime.



References:
My Forty Years with Ford, by Charles E. Sorensen & Samuel T. Williams
American Odyssey, A History of A Great City, by Robert Conot, p. 203, 206
Ford: The Man, The Times, The Company, by Allan Nevins, p. 267
The Secret Life of Henry Ford, by John Cote Dahlinger, p. 133-135
Michigan, A History of the Wolverine State, Third  Rev. Ed., by Willis F. Dunbar & George S. May, p. 432, 533-535
http://www.hemmings.com/hcc/stories/2010/04/01/hmn_feature18.html
http://archive.boatnerd.com/archivej/6-05/000002c7.htm
https://www.flickr.com/photos/48736400@N08/
http://www.superyachttimes.com/yachts/details/5265
http://www.yachtspotter.com/focard3.php?foo=FY013

The Ypsilanti "Metal" Scene

April, 2010.

A friend once recommended to me a soul food restaurant on Michigan Avenue in Ypsilanti, called "Soul on a Roll," but when I looked for it, it seemed to have gone out of business or moved. I did however notice that there was a nice big juicy abandoned plant to check out, so I made a mental note to come back once it had krauesened a little more.


I also wanted to avail myself of whatever inroads could be made against the Ford Ypsilanti Plant, which I had lately noticed was being gnawed at by the inexorable building-eaters, another sad reminder of the complete fold-up of Michigan’s industrial past, and America’s economic worth:


According to ypsilantihistoricalsociety.org, this plant was built in 1932 and continually expanded up until 1983 until it was over 987,000 square-feet. It made electrical parts for Ford cars such as generators and starters, and during WWII produced similar items for Pratt-Whitney airplanes, tanks, and military trucks. By 1982 The Ford Ypsilanti Plant employed a total of 1,800 people, and was producing "starters, ignition coils, distributors, horns, struts, air conditioner clutches, and bumper shock devices." It later became a Visteon plant before closing, and its death was eulogized by both Charlie LeDuff and Mark Maynard.

On a side note there's another Ford plant on the south side of the lake, the Ford Rawsonville Plant, named after the village of Rawsonville, a ghost town that existed before the factories came, but is now barely a memory. Started in 1823, Rawsonville went into decline and totally disappeared in 1925 when “a dam erected on the Huron River covered most of the remaining structures with the newly-formed Belleville Lake,” according to a nearby historical marker.

Anyway, since I couldn't get in the Ford plant, I reared my ugly head in the direction of Plan B. Namely a collection of mediocre buildings that sat just north of the Ford complex, but for a short jaunt through the woods over a former railroad bed which hugged the curving nape of the Huron River’s neck as it wended its way past downtown Ypsi:


Note the small footbridge.

Just before passing onto the property, I had to go through an abandoned former city park, complete with baseball diamond and forlorn swingsets:


The signage I saw on some of the buildings here seemed to indicate that the place was the Ypsilanti Iron & Metal Co., but with this really large factory style building, I had a hunch that wasn't the whole story, so I consulted the Sanborn maps.


The 1888 and 1893 Sanborn maps for Ypsilanti show that this general area was marked "Original Town," and was sparsely occupied by small concerns such as the Deubel Bros.' Huron Flour Mills, the McCollough Bros. Foundry & Machine, the Webster Bros. & Sons Planing Mill, as well as what looks to be a sprinkling of houses.

This elongated, one-story concrete factory structure first appears on the 1927 Sanborn, but it was marked as being currently vacant, "formerly" occupied the Commerce Motor Truck Co.:


Coachbuilt.com says that the Commerce Motor Car Co. existed from 1911 to 1923 in Detroit, then relocated to Ypsilanti in 1923, before finally being bought up in 1927 by the Relay Motors Corp. (which explains why the Sanborn map from that year shows this plant as vacant). They manufactured the old style chain-drive panel delivery trucks like you see in old-timey photos. Commerce Motors eventually expanded and updated their designs as automotive technology advanced, and in 1922 they started using Continental engines to power their trucks. "Claimed to be 'the wonder of motordom' the 1922 Commerce cost $2,350 and could travel at 40 mph easily."

By the time production shifted to this plant in Ypsilanti, Commerce Motors was also manufacturing four different bus chassis (from 18 to 28 passengers), as well a model of lumber truck, a dump truck, an oil truck, and a "funeral car," according to Coachbuilt. My guess is that they were a low volume manufacturer, relying on the old station-assembly method as opposed to a moving assembly line.


Other changes to this area on the 1927 Sanborn map showed that the old McCollough Bros. Foundry & Machine had become the W.M. Frisbie Machine Shop, and the Huron Grey Iron Foundry. None of those structures still existed during my visit however.


Obviously this structure has been added-onto several times since it was built for Commerce Motors in 1923.


I was surprised by how much graffiti was in here, and the fact that many of the pieces were done by names usually seen in the Detroit area. But then again I guess proximity to Eastern Michigan University might have something to do with that.


I also must say that this next one’s gotta be the creepiest piece I’ve ever seen:


The sign says, "ZERO DEFECTS IS OUR GOAL":


Sheet 21 of the 1927-1950 Sanborn shows that this complex remained in use as an automotive plant, owned by the Motor State Products Co., a division of the Detroit Harvester Co. The Amesbury Seat Mfg. Co. was located in a building immediately to its southwest.


Motor State Products manufactured automobile convertible tops here at 108 S. River Street according to what was written on the map. A Detroit Historical Society document lists the Detroit Harvester Co. at 5440-5450 W. Jefferson Avenue, Detroit (which still stands today and is the home of the Flor-Dri Supply Company).


I guess I'm glad I waited a little longer to check this place out, as it had krauesened rather nicely…lots of color to look at by this point. It sure was a great place to do graffiti, anyway. Just a huge canvas for the bombing, and plenty of space to wander around.


Venturing back outside, I began to nibble at the smorgasbord of various outbuildings scattered about this surprisingly rather large chunk of abandoned property. In fact this was like a whole abandoned neighborhood, with derelict streets and all…a huge chunk of Ypsilanti cordoned off and left to go to seed.


This is the corner of South River & Parsons (note street sign)...the arch-roofed building was originally an automobile sales & service showroom according to the 1927-1950 Sanborn map:


A house even:


A sign showing the name Ypsilanti Iron & Metal Co.:


Polk's Ann Arbor, Ypsilanti and Washtenaw County Directory for 1920 lists the Ypsilanti Iron & Metal Co.--dealers in rags and waste paper, "and all kinds of metals"--with address of 308-310 E. Michigan Ave., and Isadore Hertzburg as "proprietor."


The theme of the day seemed to be creaking doors, swinging in the breeze. There was at least one loud, swinging door on every single building here, and some of them were all-metal, making the din all the more pronounced.


As it so happens, the buildings fronting along Michigan Ave. contained a cleaner’s, a Dish Network store, and a furniture store. According to YpsiGleanings, this area was in the "Dutch Town" neighborhood of Ypsilanti (at least circa the 1930s-'40s), and Ypsilanti Iron & Metal used to be called Herzberg’s Processing back then. Which seems plausible, given that the Polk's Directory mentioned someone by that name as owning it.

I guess Herzburg (Hertzburg?) is a Dutch name?


When's the last time you saw a yellow stop sign like that?


Inside one of the smaller buildings I found the company safe:


fire occurring on May 13, 2009 called for several fire departments to respond to 103 S. Water Street   (yet another address for the site) because the water mains to these blocks had been shut in expectation of demolition, meaning that no hydrants would work. The fire was small, and believed started by a squatter.




story in the Ann Arbor News printed mere days after my visit proclaimed that a long-awaited cleanup of this site was set to kick off, announcing that the city of Ypsilanti received $600,000 in EPA Brownfield grants on May 7th, 2009 (curiously enough just before the aforementioned fire broke out).


The same article also gives addresses of 34, 38, and 40 E. Michigan Ave. for the buildings on this site, changed from the 308-310 numbering shown in the 1920 Polk's Directory. Other addresses listed are 14 S. Water Street, and 103 S. Water Street, which it refers to as the "RIM building."


A decent view of downtown Ypsi to be had from here…


Actual demolition began on May 3rd, 2010, preceded by a "kickoff party" where some very frail politicians got to take the ceremonial first whacks at a cinder block wall by pretending to know how to use a sledge hammer, a moment that was hilariously immortalized in a video clip on this news story in the Ypsilanti Citizen (luckily some less feeble men were allowed to follow up with much manlier swings afterward, saving the town of Ypsilanti some embarassment).


After deciding it was time to head home, I picked off a few shots of one last thing of interest, back by where I had parked my T-bird by the Ford plant mentioned at the top of this post. Some fishermen had taken up station by the bridges over the river, and I spotted the cobblestone ruins of what looked to be an old dam or something to an old mill that may have been on the river at this site before the Ford plant:


That area on the opposite side of the river is called Waterworks Park today, so I wonder if these ruins were part of something like that; the 1916 Sanborn seems to indicate that the "Ypsilanti Water Works and Electric Light Plant" was located almost where I was standing when I took these shots.

Sheet 27 of the 1927-1950 Sanborn shows the opposite bank to be occupied by the city water works. Perhaps then these cobblestone ruins date to a mid-1930s WPA project rather than a mid-1800s industrial concern.


On my way out of town I decided to stop by “Depot Town,” in the middle of which is the old Michigan Central RR Depot, still standing mothballed:


And across the street are the still stabilized ruins of the c.1861 Thompson Block, which recently burned:


The last time I had been in Ypsi I meant to take a gander at this old building because it looked like access could be had in the rear. I will always kick myself for passing up on that opportunity because the thing burned soon after. It had once served as an Army barracks during the Civil War, and had housed the 14th Michigan Infantry.


Ypsilanti’s efforts at preservation of its historical character are generally a standout among the other bulldozer-happy Michigan cities. If you want to know what downtown Detroit looked like in the late 1800s, visit Ypsi.



References:
Polk's Ann Arbor, Ypsilanti and Washtenaw County Directory (1920), p. 747
http://www.uawlocal898.org/Raw%20Facts/History/History898.htm
http://www.uawlocal898.org/Our%20Plant%20&%20Products.htm
Institute of Scrap Iron & Steel Yearbook, Volumes 13-16 (1952)
http://www.annarbor.com/news/ceremony-monday-will-mark-start-of-ypsilantis-water-street-cleanup-project/
http://www.annarbor.com/passions-pursuits/the-thompson-blocks-place-in-ypsilantis-history/
http://ypsiciti.com/section/News/Water+Street+demolition+begins-article-1936.html
Sanborn maps for Ypsilanti, 1888, 1893, 1899, 1909, 1916, 1927, 1927-1950
http://www.michmarkers.com/startup.asp?startpage=L1129.htm
http://www.coachbuilt.com/bui/c/commerce/commerce.htm
https://detroithistorical.org/sites/default/files/pdfs/Project%20Guidelines.pdf
http://www.ypsilantihistoricalsociety.org/history/page999995.html
http://markmaynard.com/2009/04/harvesting-the-organs-of-ypsilanti-visteon-plant/